JN

What goes into a real roof estimate

A roof price is the sum of dozens of line items many bids do not list. This walkthrough asks what we ask on the roof. Answer what you can; “Not sure” is fine. We send an itemized estimate, or tell you what we need to see. Estimates cover homes and buildings outside Florida and Alabama.

Why two bids for the same roof differ so widely

Many bids do not list the items below. Ask any bidder to put these in writing.

  1. Starter on the rakesStarter along the sloped edges, or only at the eaves.
  2. Ice and water coverageValleys, eaves, how far inside the wall, and one roll or two.
  3. Ridge typeHigh-profile cap, pre-cut hip and ridge, or cut from 3-tab.
  4. Drip edge or gutter apronMetal at the edges, and whether it goes over or under the underlayment.
  5. Valley methodOpen metal, closed-cut or woven.
  6. Pipe jacksLead, plastic or metal-based, one for every pipe.
  7. Chimney flashing and cricketStep and counter flashing, and a cricket where the chimney is wide.
  8. VentilationIntake and exhaust brought into balance.
  9. DeckingReplaced where it is soft, once the old roof is off.
  10. Layers to tear offEvery extra layer is more labor and more disposal.
  11. Access and disposalWhere the dumpster sits and what has to be protected.

The walkthrough

Answer what you can. Every question has a Not sure, and each Not sure is something we check on the roof.

Estimates are for homes and buildings outside Florida and Alabama. Without JavaScript this page cannot attach your answers to a message. Read the questions below, then call 239‑791‑0646 or email contact@justennewton.com and tell us what you know.

01What is the roof made of?

Pick the closest match. If it looks like none of these, choose Not sure and we will identify it on the roof.

Asbestos-cement shingles are regulated. Testing and state and local asbestos rules come before any removal. We don’t break or remove them as part of an estimate.

02Where is the roof?

Pick the city, town or county that issues the building permit. For these 11 Colorado places we show what the local code says, with sources, on the next screen.

03What is the shingle rated for?

The rating is usually printed on the bundle wrapper; if you have a leftover bundle, the product name is on it. On the roof, we tell product lines apart with a shingle gauge, which measures exposure and thickness.

Side view of shingles on a slope with exposure, thickness and the shingle gauge labeled
04How is the impact-resistant shingle built?

Modern asphalt shingles are built on a fiberglass mat. Impact-resistant lines either reinforce the back with a fabric or scrim, or use SBS (styrene-butadiene-styrene) polymer-modified asphalt that flexes instead of fracturing. Class 4 is the highest impact rating under UL 2218 (UL).

Cross-section of a standard shingle and an SBS polymer-modified shingle, both built on a fiberglass mat
05What is the exposure of the shingles?

Exposure is how much of each shingle shows. It decides which replacement shingles will match on a repair.

Two shingle stacks showing a 5 inch exposure and a 5 5/8 inch metric exposure
06What is on the ridges and hips?

Ridge cap covers the peak where two slopes meet. The type changes both the look and the labor.

Example photo: Asphalt ridge cap shingles running along a hip and ridge
07How many pieces are broken or missing?

A rough count from the ground is enough. We count them on the roof.

08If this is a repair: can the existing roofing be worked?

Old roofing can be too brittle to repair. On asphalt shingles, the sealant can tear the mat out of the shingle being lifted, leaving it stuck to the course below. We test this on the roof before promising a repair.

09What is on the roof now, bottom to top?

Order matters. Spray foam over TPO is a different roof from TPO over foam, and each layer is another tear-off. Start at the deck and add each layer going up.

Without scripts, list the layers from the deck up in the note on the form, for example: deck, insulation, EPDM.

10How many roof layers are there in total?

Count every layer down to the deck, including old membranes, insulation and coatings. A rough count is fine.

11Is there spray foam (SPF)? Where does it sit?

Spray foam is a rigid, sprayed-on foam that is usually coated. It looks like a thick, slightly bumpy, painted surface.

12Is there TPO?

TPO is a white, tan or gray single-ply membrane with heat-welded seams.

13Built-up roofing or coal-tar pitch?

Older built-up and coal-tar pitch roofs can have asbestos in the felts or flashing cement. That is regulated and tested before anything is disturbed. We take a sample; we don’t guess.

14Any signs the roof is wet inside?

Saturated insulation must come off; dry insulation can sometimes stay. We confirm with moisture readings or a core cut on the roof. Pick all that apply.

15What is on the roof edge?

Coping is the metal cap over the top of a parapet wall. Gravel stop and drip edge are the metal strips at an edge with no wall.

16Is a termination bar visible where the membrane meets a wall?

A termination bar is a thin metal strip screwed along the top edge of the membrane on a wall, holding it down, usually with a bead of sealant over it.

17How many air conditioners sit on the roof?

Count separate condensing or window-style air conditioners. Rooftop heating and cooling units are the next question.

18How many rooftop units (RTUs) for heating and cooling?

An RTU is a large packaged box that heats, cools or both, sitting on a curb on the roof. Each one needs its curb flashed.

19How many vents, drains or pipes come through the roof?

Count roof drains, scuppers, plumbing and exhaust vents, and any other pipes. A rough range is fine.

20When was the roof last replaced?

The year is enough. If you do not know it, skip this or choose Not sure.

21What is the flashing metal?

Flashing is the metal at valleys, walls, chimneys and edges. Copper has a brown or green color, lead is soft and dull gray, terne is dull gray and often painted; galvanized or painted steel is gray or painted.

22Is there a starter shingle at the edges?

Starter on the rakes adds a sealed edge along the sloped sides, which helps resist wind lift. Eaves are the bottom edges. Rakes are the sloped side edges.

Plan view of a roof plane with starter shingle along the eave and along both rakes
23How are the roof edges finished?

Drip edge is metal along the roof edge that sends water off the deck. At the eaves a gutter apron goes under the underlayment; at the rakes the drip edge goes over it.

Edge sections: a gutter apron at the eave under the underlayment and a drip edge at the rake over it
Drip edge on the rakes?
Gutter apron at the eaves?
24Is there ice and water barrier in the valleys?

Ice and water barrier is a self-sealing membrane under the roofing in the places water gets pushed.

25Is there ice and water barrier at the eaves?

International Residential Code R905.1.2 requires the ice barrier to extend from the eave to at least 24 inches inside the exterior wall line, where your local code requires an ice barrier. On roofs 8:12 or steeper, some codes also require it at least 36 inches up the slope from the eave. A deep overhang can mean one roll does not reach.

Ask us what your local code requires for this roof type.

Section at the eave: the ice and water barrier runs from the eave to at least 24 inches inside the exterior wall lineExample photo: Self-adhered ice and water membrane in overlapping sheets on a roof deck, running up from the eave
At the eaves?
One roll or two?
Does it reach at least 24 inches inside the exterior wall line?
26Any history of ice dams or ice damage?

Ice dams are ridges of ice at the eaves that back meltwater up under the roofing. Winter ceiling stains along exterior walls are a common sign.

27How are the valleys finished?

A valley is where two slopes meet in a V. Open valleys show a strip of metal. Closed-cut valleys are covered by cut shingles. Woven valleys interlace the shingles from both sides.

28What kind of pipe flashings are on the roof?

Pipe jacks, also called pipe boots, seal the plumbing vent pipes where they pass through the roof. We list each one on the estimate.

Example photo: Plumbing vent pipe with a metal flashing collar on an asphalt shingle roof
Type of pipe jack
How many pipes come through the roof?
29Is there a chimney?

Count a masonry chimney that comes through the roof surface.

30How wide is the chimney along the roof?

We ask because a chimney wider than 30 inches needs a cricket (a small peaked saddle) on its up-slope side: IRC R903.2.2, where your local code requires it.

Roof plane with a chimney, a cricket above it, step flashing up both sides and counter flashingExample photo: Copper cricket, a small peaked saddle, set on the up-slope side of a chimney over underlayment
31How is the chimney flashed?

Step flashing runs up the side in pieces. Counter flashing is the cover metal that laps over it, either set into the chimney or mounted on its surface.

Example photo: Metal flashing at the base of a brick chimney on an asphalt shingle roof
32Does the flashing run at least 4 inches up the chimney?

A rough look from the ground is fine. We measure it on the roof.

33Are there skylights?

A curb-mounted skylight sits on a raised frame. A deck-mounted one sits flat on the roof deck. Reflashing keeps the unit and replaces the metal around it.

How many?
How are they mounted?
What is the plan for them?
34Does the roof run into a wall?

That means a dormer or a second story rising from the roof. Step flashing is the row of small bent metal pieces along the wall. A kick-out is the angled piece at the bottom that sends water into the gutter instead of behind the siding.

Roof runs into a wall?
Step flashing visible along the wall?
Kick-out flashing at the bottom of the wall?
35Where the roof meets a wall, how is it flashed?

We check whether the existing step flashing can be reused and whether it’s properly interlaced with the shingles.

36Is the existing step flashing in shape to reuse?

Step flashing is the row of small bent metal pieces along the wall. We check each piece on the roof.

37Is there kick-out flashing at the bottom of the wall?

A kick-out is the angled piece at the bottom of the wall that sends water into the gutter instead of behind the siding.

38What kind of exhaust vents are on the roof?

Ventilation works when intake and exhaust are balanced. On a full tear-off we check intake and exhaust against current code. Pick all that apply.

39How many exhaust vents are on the roof?

Count each box vent, turbine or fan. A ridge vent counts as one.

40Are the exhaust vents within about 2 to 3 feet of the ridge?

IRC R806.2 places the upper vents not more than 3 feet below the ridge, measured vertically, when vent area is figured at the 1/300 ratio.

41What intake vents does the roof have?

Intake at the eaves should roughly match exhaust at the ridge.

42How many bath or kitchen exhaust caps are on the roof?

These are the round or square caps over bathroom and kitchen fans, the kind often made by Broan. Each one needs its own flashing.

43What size are the bath or kitchen exhaust caps?

Model numbers are examples so you can match what you see; other brands make the same sizes.

44How many furnace or water-heater flues come through the roof?

These are the metal pipes that carry combustion gases out. Each one needs its own flashing.

45What is the flue pipe (stack) size?

The pipe size is printed on the pipe or the appliance, or measure across the pipe. A rough size is fine.

46What size is the flue cap?

The cap is the cover on top of the pipe. It is either the same size as the pipe or wider.

47Is the flue double-wall (B-vent) pipe?

B-vent is double-wall metal pipe, with an inner and an outer wall. Not sure is fine.

48What is the roof deck made of?

We find out how much decking needs replacing once the old roof is off. Soft spots you have felt from inside help us plan for it.

Deck type
Known soft spots?
49How many layers of roofing are on it now?

Local codes generally limit how many layers a roof can carry. Extra layers mean more tear-off and disposal.

Example photo: A hand lifts the shingle edge at the fascia, showing stacked layers of roofing
50How many layers of felt are under the shingles?

Old roofs can have five or six layers of felt under two layers of shingles. We count them at tear-off.

Example photo: Black felt underlayment laid in overlapping courses on a roof deck beside a brick chimney
51How steep is the roof, and how tall is the building?

Steepness changes the safety gear and the time on the roof. Answer from the ground; do not climb up to check.

Steepness
Stories
52How big is the roof?

One square is 100 square feet of roof surface. If you do not know it, skip this: the address lets us measure.

53What is access like around the building?

If materials have to be carried around the building instead of set at the eave, that’s added labor. A dumpster or trailer also needs room close to the work, and landscaping or pools near the walls need protecting.

Room in the driveway for a dumpster or trailer?
Landscaping or pools near the walls?
54What about the gutters?

Gutters and gutter guards come off and go back on around roof work.

55Are the gutters hung below the gutter apron, so water runs into them?

The gutter apron is the metal at the eave that guides water into the gutter instead of behind it.

56How big are the gutters, and how are they hung?

Spikes and ferrules are long nails through a sleeve. Hidden hangers are brackets inside the gutter. A rough size from the ground is fine.

57What are the gutters made of?

Aluminum is light, painted or unpainted; steel is heavier and gray or painted; copper is brown or green.

58Do the gutters have guards?

Gutter guards are covers or screens over the gutter.

59Are there rules for the work?

Some neighborhoods and districts review the materials and colors of a roof before work starts. The city code facts come from the panel shown after you pick where the roof is. Pick all that apply.

What 11 Colorado building departments say

Each value links to the page it came from. Checked Oct 15, 2026. Codes change; we confirm with the building department before work. Where we found nothing in a primary source, it says so.

Local roofing code facts for 11 Colorado jurisdictions
JurisdictionAdopted codesReroof permitIce barrierRe-cover and layer limitImpact (Class 4) ruleFire classPermit search
Denver City and CountyIRC 2024, IBC 20242025 Denver Building and Fire Code amends the 2024 I-codes; effective Dec 31, 2025Required (roofing not in DBC 130.3 exempt list); quick permit without plan review possible. 2015 guide: repairs over 10% need one sourceNot required: Denver Table R301.2 lists ice barrier underlayment required = No source2015 city guideline (dated): max two layers; beyond that tear off to deck. No 2025 Denver amendment to IRC reroofing found sourceNot found in a primary source2025 Colorado Wildfire Resiliency Code applies in mapped WUI areas (Appendix T). No citywide Class A rule found sourceSearch permits
AuroraIRC 2021, IBC 2021Aurora City Code ch. 22 amends the 2021 IRC and IBCRequired: city reroof guide answers "Is a permit required to re-roof my house? Yes." Repair threshold not found sourceRequired: Aurora sec. 22-186 Table R301.2(1) says "Ice Shield Underlayment required: Yes" sourceNot found in a primary sourceNot found in a primary sourceNo Class A rule found; Aurora sec. 22-182 says the Urban-Wildland Interface Code is not adopted sourceSearch permits
ArvadaIRC 2024, IBC 2024City of Arvada amendments to the 2024 codes, in effect July 1, 2026Required; exempt if replacing up to 25% of roofing, max 100 sq ft per year sourceRequired citywide under the 2026 codes (a 2020 memo saying it was not required is superseded) sourceNo local limit found; overlay allowed where 2024 IRC R908.4 permits sourceCity's 2026 roofing guide says Class 4 is required (cites Sec. 18-191; ordinance text not reviewed) sourceClass A required in wildfire zones; Class B allowed elsewhere where code allows. Wildfire-zone reroofs need plan review sourceSearch permits
Boulder cityIRC 2024, IBC 2024Boulder Revised Code ch. 10-5 and 10-5.5 amend the 2024 IBC and IRCRequired: roofing is not in Boulder's 105.2 exempt list. Repair threshold not verified on a live city page sourceNot required: Boulder Table R301.2 says "Ice barrier underlayment required = NO" sourceOverlays allowed with a pre-roof inspection. Layer limit not verified on a live city page sourceNot found in a primary sourceClass A roof coverings required citywide (R902.1 amended); wood shakes and shingles banned sourceSearch permits
GoldenIRC 2024, IBC 2024Required for roofing/re-roofing; minor roof repairs or replacement of 10% or less exempt sourceRequired for all new and re-roofing sourceCity page conflicts: one overlay allowed on asphalt or wood shingles, but repairs over 25% need full replacement to deck sourceNot found in a primary sourceWood shakes/shingles Class A, other roofing at least Class C; Golden Wildfire Resiliency Code in WUI from June 10, 2026 sourceSearch permits
LakewoodIRC 2021, IBC 20212021 codes as adopted and amended by Lakewood, effective June 30, 2023Required before tear-off; repairs under 100 sq ft exempt sourceNot required: city handout says an ice barrier underlayment is not required sourceNo overlays: existing roof coverings on dwellings must be removed to the deck sourceNot found in a primary sourceClass A fire rating required for all roof coverings. City wildfire code adoption status not confirmed sourceSearch permits
LittletonIRC 2024, IBC 2024City Code Title 4, Ch. 1 amends the 2024 I-codesRequired above one square (100 sq ft); one square or less is a repair sourceRequired at eaves of conditioned structures, 2 ft inside the exterior wall line (ASTM D1970) sourceFull tear-off to deck; no overlays (policy allows membrane-type overlays) sourceNot found in a primary source2024 IWUIC adopted; additional requirements may apply in WUI hazard zones. No citywide Class A rule found sourceSearch permits
CentennialIRC 2021, IBC 2021Centennial Municipal Code ch. 18 amends the 2021 IRC and IBCRequired when repairs exceed 100 sq ft; under 100 sq ft exempt sourceRequired on all roofs (Table R301.2(1): ice barrier required = YES) sourceReplacement removes all layers to deck; repairs over 25% of roof require complete tear-off sourceNot found in a primary sourceCWRC effective June 30, 2026 in Low/Moderate zones; applies to roof replacements of 25% or more sourceSearch permits
Castle Rock townIRC 2024, IBC 2024Town amendments (Municipal Code Title 15) took effect June 30, 2026Required before replacing a roof. Repair threshold not found sourceRequired, except detached accessory structures without conditioned floor area (FAQ cites 2018 IRC) source100% tear-off incl. underlayment to deck; roof overlays not permitted sourceNot found in a primary sourceRe-roofs may be subject to the 2025 Colorado Wildfire Resiliency Code by hazard class sourceSearch permits
Evergreen unincorporated Jefferson CountyIRC 2024, IBC 20242024 Jefferson County Building Code Supplements, effective July 1, 2026Required; repairs under 25% of roof area and not more than 2 squares exempt sourceRequired per R905.1.2 for asphalt, metal shingles, roll roofing, slate, wood shingles and shakes sourceOne layer of asphalt shingles only; no overlays, complete tear-off required sourceNot found in a primary sourceClass A roof assemblies required in the county WUI Overlay District (wildfire rules from July 1, 2026) sourceSearch permits
Morrison townIRC 2024, IBC 2024Morrison Municipal Code secs. 9-1-3 to 9-1-13 amend the adopted codesTown permit form lists "Roof" as an improvement type. No threshold or rule text found sourceRequired: ASTM D1970 ice barrier at eaves (town amendment) source2009 town guide (dated): all existing layers must be removed (SAFEbuilt re-roofing guide, 10.1.09) sourceNot found in a primary sourceTown adopted the 2025 Colorado Wildfire Resiliency Code (sec. 9-1-2 M). Class A specifics not reviewed sourceNo public permit search found

Questions people ask

№ 01

Why don’t you post prices?

A roof price depends on the answers above and on measurements taken on the roof. A single number posted without them would be a guess. We send an itemized estimate that lists what is in it.

№ 02

What’s a square?

A roofing square is 100 square feet of roof surface. Pitch, hips, valleys and dormers add surface and cuts, so the roof is usually larger than the footprint of the house.

№ 03

Why does starter on the rakes matter?

Starter on the rakes adds a sealed edge along the sloped sides, which helps resist wind lift.

№ 04

Do I need ice and water barrier?

Where your local code requires an ice barrier, yes. IRC R905.1.2 requires it to extend from the eave to at least 24 inches inside the exterior wall line. Ask your local building department, and ask any bidder to say in writing where the barrier goes.

№ 05

Can you estimate from photos?

Photos let us ask better questions, and they often narrow the range of questions that matter. The final price comes after we measure, because pitch, layers, decking and flashing details do not show reliably in pictures. You can email photos to contact@justennewton.com.

Photo credits

Photos marked “Example photo” are free-licensed images of other roofs. They are not our projects. Each was cropped and resized.

  • Slate: “Slate roof” by selkovjr, CC BY 2.0. Source
  • Clay tile: “Peru - Cusco 236 - hiking above the city and the Chacán cave” by mckaysavage, CC BY 2.0. Source
  • 3-tab asphalt shingles: “UIUC Arboretum 20070923 img 1927.jpg” by Dori, CC BY 3.0. Source
  • Metal: “Standing seam metal roof 3” by Wikideas1, CC0 1.0. Source
  • Wood shake: “Wood Tiled Roof Pattern” by shaire productions, CC BY 2.0. Source
  • Chimney flashing: “Flashing” by DolfinDans, CC BY 2.0. Source
  • Ridge cap: “Ridge cap” by DolfinDans, CC BY 2.0. Source
  • Pipe flashing: “Getting Started” by DolfinDans, CC BY 2.0. Source
  • Shingle layers: “Two layers” by DolfinDans, CC BY 2.0. Source
  • Low-slope membrane: “FinishedEPDMcoveredRoof.jpg” by KVDP, public domain. Source
  • Ice and water barrier: “Sheeting and ice water shield over portions of roof two” by U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Northeast Region, public domain (U.S. federal government work). Source
  • Felt underlayment: “NPS mason installs copper flashing between the reconstructed brick chimney and the soon-to-be installed cedar roof” by NPS Photo, public domain (U.S. federal government work). Source
  • Chimney cricket: “Installed cricket” by Ctd 2005, CC BY 2.0. Source

Estimates for homes and buildings outside Florida and Alabama.